Rebel Without a Copyright?

Movies & Music Blog

DVD Jon Lands Dream Job Stateside - Michael Robertson, the bold but oft-sued genius behind MP3.com and Linspire, brings the iconic and frequently prosecuted Norwegian media hacker to California for his latest venture. This should be interesting. By Annalee Newitz. [Movies & Music]

Though more than a month old now, I came across this interesting story about Jon Lech Johansen, a Norweigan hacker, or reverse engineer as he usually calls himself. Jon's stock in trade is producing hacks or programs to disable DRM (Digital Rights Management) components included with much of today's commercial media. Like myself, Jon is leary of overzealous copyright protection but he has taken up the fight in a slightly different way. Not only are Jon's actions illegal under US law (and recently, Norway's), but he continues his work flagrantly out in the open.

The second component of this story is Johansen's recent move to the United States. As he said, "In Norway, you have the same laws (as in the United States) now," he says, "so it makes no difference if I'm doing my work here or there." Johansen has taken a job with tech entrepreneur Michael Robertson, who currently operates several online media portals. This partnership offers Jon a financial and legal umbrella under which to practice his reverse engineering.

As is the case with the rebellious and the uncompromising, Jon is easy to admire in principle. He uses his considerable skills to ensure freedom of and free access to, media. I believe though that we must be cautious of too much disregard for the law in the quest for freer media. The persistent illegal file trading community is proof that laws must be adapted and changed, and that is exactly where substantial victory will be found; in the changing of the laws, not their continuous violation. Flagrant and widespread disobediance untempered by an intellgient discourse can lead down a slippery slope of ever harsher laws and punishments, making 'free media' a truly dangerous concept.

Exactly

It is almost scaring thinking that at some point in the future there might not even be copyrighting. We seem to be so against the idea of copyright as consumers, but completely for it as musicians and filmmakers alike. The only reason the musicians and film makers want the copyrighting to exist is so they can maintain substantial money for their work. If everyone had something copyrighted for the sole purpose of maintaining their creative integrity, there would be a lot less need for suing. Trading music wouldn't be illegal either under this idea, as long as you don't take the music and try to say it is your own creation. "Reverse engineering" is a field that I believe is only necessary due to our own corruption. Someday we will appreciate hackers alike for their contributions as being freedom seekers in a sense. They usually only get in trouble for pointing out flaws in security structures or exposing secrets that the government didn't want exposed.

-Technar out-